Councillors Concerned Debate Is Being Stifled At South Cumbria Meetings.

Councillors have raised concerns that debate is being stifled at Westmorland and Furness Council meetings after some members were unable to ask their questions within the allocated time.

The concerns were raised during recent full council meetings, where councillors questioned members of the administration about decisions taken at cabinet meetings. A 30-minute limit is normally allocated for councillors to ask questions following cabinet meetings. However, some opposition members said lengthy responses from cabinet members meant that not everyone had the opportunity to put their questions forward before the allotted time ended.

Labour councillor Tony Callister, representing Dalton South, said he believed the situation was unfair after some opposition councillors were unable to ask their questions. He argued that the length of responses was contributing to the problem and preventing other elected members from having their say. The issue was also raised during a separate section of the meeting where councillors were given an opportunity to ask questions. Again, the 30-minute time limit expired before all members who wanted to speak had been able to do so.

Council chairman Doug Rathbone, councillor for Kendal South, acknowledged the concerns and said he would look into the matter alongside the council's director of law and governance. Members were also invited to send their concerns to the chairman and monitoring officer for further discussion.

Reform UK councillor Hazel Edwards, representing Hawcoat and Newbarns, subsequently expressed concerns about the way council meetings were being conducted. Speaking to the Local Democracy Reporting Service, she said she believed the current arrangements were limiting meaningful debate.

The concerns centre on the balance between keeping council meetings within a reasonable timeframe and ensuring elected representatives have enough opportunity to scrutinise decisions. Question periods are designed to allow councillors to challenge and seek clarification from those responsible for council decisions.

For opposition councillors, having sufficient time to ask questions is an important part of holding the administration to account. If members are unable to speak before a time limit expires, they may feel that they have not been given a full opportunity to represent their constituents.

At the same time, council meetings need to operate within practical time limits, particularly when there are large numbers of questions or several cabinet decisions to discuss. The latest disagreement therefore highlights the challenge faced by councils in ensuring meetings remain efficient while allowing proper democratic scrutiny.

The chairman's decision to review the issue with the council's legal and governance officers could lead to discussions about how future question sessions are managed. Possible changes could involve reviewing the length of responses, the way questions are prioritised or the amount of time allocated to different sections of meetings.

For residents across South Cumbria, the issue is significant because council meetings provide one of the main opportunities for elected representatives to publicly question decisions affecting local communities. The concerns also come as Westmorland and Furness Council continues to oversee services and decisions across a large area, meaning councillors from different communities need opportunities to raise issues affecting their wards.

The debate over speaking time demonstrates the importance of ensuring that all political groups have a meaningful opportunity to participate in council business. For now, the chairman has indicated that the concerns will be considered with the relevant council officers, while councillors have been asked to provide further details about their experiences. The outcome of that review could determine whether changes are made to the way question sessions are organised at future meetings. 

Got a news story or tip to share? Contact our editorial team by emailing news@lakelandpost.co.uk or call us directly on 0333 090 2080.