Carlisle Man Denies Manslaughter Charge Over Mother's Death
The trial of a Carlisle man accused of gross negligence manslaughter has continued at Carlisle Crown Court, where jurors heard evidence from a consultant clinical psychologist regarding the defendant's mental capacity and decision making abilities.
Stewart Irwin, 56, denies the charge relating to the death of his 74 year old mother, Veronica Irwin, who died in July 2023 after being taken to hospital from the flat where they lived together. Prosecutors allege he failed to seek medical assistance promptly after she suffered a fall, resulting in her remaining on the bathroom floor for an extended period before emergency services were contacted.
The court heard evidence from consultant clinical psychologist Dr Nicholas Todd, who carried out a detailed assessment of Irwin. Dr Todd told jurors that the defendant's IQ was within the low average range but said there was no evidence of clinically significant autism or any impairment that would have prevented him from making independent decisions.
During cross examination, the psychologist told the court that Irwin described attempting to help his mother after she fell but claimed she had repeatedly refused his assistance. The psychologist also said Irwin spoke about a difficult relationship with his mother, describing her as having mood swings and controlling behaviour.
Prosecutors allege that Irwin owed his mother a duty of care and failed to obtain medical help sooner despite her deteriorating condition. The prosecution argues this alleged failure amounted to gross negligence, leading to her death. The defence disputes the allegation, and Irwin has entered a plea of not guilty.
The trial is continuing at Carlisle Crown Court, where further evidence will be presented before the jury considers its verdict. As with all criminal proceedings, the defendant is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.
Got a news story or tip to share? Contact our editorial team by emailing news@lakelandpost.co.uk or call us directly on 0333 090 2080.