Cockermouth Housing Development Rejected Over Red Squirrel Protection Concerns

Plans to redevelop the former Cumbria Fire and Rescue Service headquarters in Cockermouth have been refused after councillors raised concerns about protecting local red squirrels.

The proposal, submitted by West Cumbrian businessman Bill Dobie, involved constructing a four-storey apartment block and six houses on land along Station Road.

However, members of Cumberland Council’s planning committee voted against the development at a meeting held at Allerdale House in Workington on Wednesday, October 21, 2026. Although planning officers had recommended approval, councillors said they were not satisfied that the ecological information adequately addressed the risks to the protected species.

The development had attracted significant opposition, particularly over proposals to remove between 50 and 60 trees from the site.

The planning application was initially submitted in May 2023 and received approval in September that year. It was subsequently brought back before the committee after concerns emerged that the ecological reports submitted with the original application were outdated.

Further assessments were requested, including an independent survey of red squirrel activity in and around the proposed development site.

Councillors were told that the survey had identified squirrel activity within the site and a surrounding 50-metre buffer zone. Measures were proposed to maintain woodland corridors and allow squirrels to move through the upper canopy of trees.

Despite these proposals, objectors argued that removing dozens of trees could create gaps in the woodland canopy and disrupt the animals’ movement and habitat.

Campaigners also stressed the importance of meeting legal obligations to protect red squirrels, which are protected under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981.

During the meeting, the council’s ecologist warned that there would be a period between the removal of existing trees and the establishment of replacement planting.

In her professional assessment, the proposed measures would not adequately compensate for the ecological impact during this period.

Planning officers maintained that the woodland corridor would remain in place while mitigation planting was completed. The applicant’s representative also argued that the site was previously developed land and said the woodland could be managed and improved as part of the scheme.

The representative added that checks for squirrel dreys would be carried out before any trees were felled.

However, councillors remained divided over whether these measures would sufficiently protect the local wildlife population.

Councillor Roger Dobson expressed concern about whether the red squirrels could survive the proposed development. Councillor Andrew Semple also highlighted the importance of protecting Cumbria’s natural environment.

Councillor Dobson subsequently proposed refusing the application, with Councillor Semple seconding the motion.

The proposal has generated considerable public opposition over several years. Since the committee’s March 2024 meeting, a further 319 objections had been received, with Protect Cockermouth Wildlife among the groups campaigning against the development.

The eventual refusal prompted applause from members of the public attending the meeting.

The decision highlights the challenges facing planning authorities as they balance housing development with the protection of local wildlife and sensitive habitats.For Cockermouth, the outcome represents a significant development in a long-running planning dispute, with red squirrel conservation emerging as a decisive issue in the committee’s decision.

Got a news story or tip to share? Contact our editorial team by emailing news@lakelandpost.co.uk or call us directly on 0333 090 2080.